Advocate General at Court of Justice of the European Union concludes against the rejection, by the Netherlands, of a fiscal unity between sister companies and between a parent and sub-subsidiary

Publication date 27 February 2014

Under Dutch legislation, a fiscal unity for corporate income purposes cannot be established between sister companies of a foreign parent, or between sister companies and the foreign parent. This also applies to a domestic parent company that holds a domestic sub-subsidiary through an intermediate holding company resident abroad. The question that has arisen is whether this is in accordance with the European freedom of establishment. On February 27, 2014, the Advocate General (AG) at the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) issued an Opinion on this issue, in response to the request for a preliminary ruling from the CJEU that was submitted by the Amsterdam Court of Appeals in respect of three cases, one of which is being litigated by KPMG Meijburg & Co on behalf of one of its clients.

Relevant facts and the dispute

These cases, which the CJEU has decided to deal with as ‘joined cases’, i.e. they will be heard together in a single proceeding, concern internationally operating businesses that are also active in the Netherlands with numerous Dutch-resident operating, holding and/or financing companies. In one of the cases, the Dutch companies are subsidiaries of a German parent company; in the other two cases, the Dutch companies are held by a Dutch parent through German intermediate holding companies.

The requests that were filed all invoked the European freedom of establishment as substantiation for including the Dutch companies in a fiscal unity, despite the fact that the common parent company or the intermediate holding companies are all established in Germany. The Dutch tax authorities rejected the requests. One of the reasons given for this rejection was the alleged risk of losses being deducted in both the Netherlands and Germany, i.e. international double loss set-off.

The AG’s opinion

The first conclusion drawn by AG Kokott is that in all three cases the freedom of establishment is restricted, because the taxpayers are being denied access to the fiscal unity regime. The taxpayers are therefore being disadvantaged. In particular, she concludes that the three situations are comparable to situations permitted under Dutch law. The second conclusion drawn by AG Kokott is that the restriction cannot be justified on the grounds of reasons of overriding public interest. She rejected the arguments put forward by the Netherlands, i.e. the need to preserve tax coherency, including the necessity of avoiding national and international double loss set-off.

Commentary KPMG Meijburg & Co

This Opinion is in line with earlier CJEU case law and will be applauded by many internationally operating companies. If the CJEU follows this Opinion, the Netherlands, and perhaps also some other Member States, will have to (further) amend their legislation. It should be noted that this does not involve cross-border loss set-off; the loss set-off only relates to Dutch profits and losses and, to this extent, does not contain any cross-border elements. It is important to note that requests for preliminary rulings do not suspend national deadlines. To preserve your rights timely action is required. A request for a fiscal unity can be made up to three months after the desired commencement date.

We will now have to wait and see whether the CJEU will rule in accordance with the AG’s Opinion. However, the Opinions issued by Advocates General are often an important indication as to how the CJEU will in fact rule.

Click here to download the memorandum in pdf format

   

Investment in the Netherlands 2014

22 September, 2014 | Publications

Each year KPMG publishes an updated edition of ‘Investment in the Netherlands’, which outlines the Dutch investment climate.…

Read more

OECD releases first recommendations action pl...

17 September, 2014 | News

On September 16, 2013, the OECD launched the first set of reports following its Action Plan to deal with base erosion and profit shifting (“BEPS”). The reports address 7 of the…

Read more

International Tax Newsletter - August 2014

08 September, 2014 | News

Every month we publish an e-newsletter which gives you an overview of international tax developments being reported globally by KPMG member firms in the American, Africa, Europe and ASPAC…

Read more

EU Tax Law app now available in the Apple App...

03 September, 2014 | News

KPMG Meijburg has launched a Beta version of an EU Tax Law app that contains all the rulings (including opinions) from the Court of Justice of the EU for Direct Tax, VAT and Social…

Read more

International Tax Newsletter - July 2014

14 August, 2014 | News

Every month we publish an e-newsletter which gives you an overview of international tax developments being reported globally by KPMG member firms in the American, Africa, Europe and ASPAC…

Read more

New tax treaty between China and the Netherla...

13 August, 2014 | News

The new tax treaty between China and the Netherlands will enter into force at the end of August and apply to income received after January 1, 2015. A number of changes that have been made…

Read more

European Court of Justice rules against Danis...

18 July, 2014 | News

The Court of Justice of the European Union held that a Danish provision for recapture of losses sustained in a foreign permanent establishment constitutes a restriction of the freedom of…

Read more

Taxation of Cross-Border Mergers and Acquisit...

11 July, 2014 | Publications

KPMG’s Taxation of Cross-Border Mergers and Acquisitions features information from 60 countries on their current laws and regulations and the potential implications for tax-efficient…

Read more

Does temporal ringfencing facilitate creativi...

08 July, 2014 | Publications

Source: Weekblad Fiscaal Recht, 2014/846, pp. 846-856.Author: Laura Cats and Bauco Suvaal On May 27, 2014 the Deputy Minister of Finance, Mr. Wiebes, presented the Memorandum in response…

Read more

International Tax Newsletter - June 2014

07 July, 2014 | News

Every month we publish an e-newsletter which gives you an overview of international tax developments being reported globally by KPMG member firms in the American, Africa, Europe and ASPAC…

Read more

New Tax Regulation between the Netherlands an...

24 June, 2014 | News

On June 10, 2014 the new bilateral rules for the avoidance of double taxation between the Netherlands – including the Caribbean part – and Curaçao (“BRNC”) were announced and…

Read more

EU Council of Ministers agrees with amendment...

23 June, 2014 | News

The amendment means that payments received on cross-border hybrid loans will be excluded from tax exemption as from January 1, 2016.…

Read more

Court of Justice of the European Union rules ...

12 June, 2014 | News

On June 12, 2014 the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) ruled that Dutch legislation on the fiscal unity for corporate income tax purposes is contrary to the European freedom of…

Read more

International Tax Newsletter - May 2014

10 June, 2014 | News

Every month we publish an e-newsletter which gives you an overview of international tax developments being reported globally by KPMG member firms in the American, Africa, Europe and ASPAC…

Read more

Important decision by CJEU on the dividend wi...

06 June, 2014 | News

The Court of Justice of the European Union in Luxembourg has concluded that the 8.3% dividend withholding tax pursuant to the BRK is permissible subject to certain conditions. …

Read more

International Tax Newsletter - april 2014

12 May, 2014 | News

Every month we publish an e-newsletter which gives you an overview of international tax developments being reported globally by KPMG member firms in the American, Africa, Europe and ASPAC…

Read more

Corporate and Indirect Tax Rate Survey 2014

28 April, 2014 | Publications

Indirect and corporate tax rates on a rollercoaster ride: KPMG International survey reviews the ups and downs…

Read more

Dutch State Profit Share – Recent Supreme Cou...

22 April, 2014 | News

On April 11, 2014, the Dutch Supreme Court provided guidance regarding on the treatment of tariff income for Dutch State Profit Share purposes.…

Read more

International Tax Newsletter - March 2014

07 April, 2014 | News

Every month we publish an e-newsletter which gives you an overview of international tax developments being reported globally by KPMG member firms in the American, Africa, Europe and ASPAC…

Read more

Competitive Alternatives, 2014 Edition

31 March, 2014 | Publications

Of the countries in Western Europe, the Netherlands is the most attractive for foreign companies wishing to locate in this part of Europe.…

Read more

OECD issued public discussion draft on tax ch...

28 March, 2014 | News

On March 24, 2014, the OECD released a public discussion draft on the tax challenges of the digital economy, as part of its base erosion and profit-shifting action plan (Action 1).…

Read more

European Council agreed to adopt amendments t...

21 March, 2014 | News

On March 20, 2014 Luxembourg has agreed to a proposed revision of the EU Savings Directive. This clears the path for the EU Council of Ministers to adopt the amendments in the Savings…

Read more

OECD issued public discussion drafts on neutr...

20 March, 2014 | News

On 19 March 2014, the OECD released two public discussion drafts on the development of model treaty provisions and recommendations for the design of domestic rules to neutralize the effect…

Read more

OECD issued public discussion draft on tax tr...

17 March, 2014 | News

Recently, the OECD issued a public discussion draft on tax treaty abuse as part of its base erosion and profit-shifting action plan.…

Read more

International Tax Newsletter - February 2014

07 March, 2014 | News

Every month we publish an e-newsletter which gives you an overview of international tax developments being reported globally by KPMG member firms in the American, Africa, Europe and ASPAC…

Read more

Action required: new rules on Swiss Principal...

28 February, 2014 | News

Via this alert we would like to inform you about the recently published ‘guidelines’ from the Swiss federal tax administration on the taxation of Principal Companies, which could have a…

Read more

International Tax Newsletter - January 2014

11 February, 2014 | News

Every month we publish an e-newsletter which gives you an overview of international tax developments being reported globally by KPMG member firms in the American, Africa, Europe and ASPAC…

Read more

Important advice by Advocate General at CJEU ...

06 February, 2014 | News

The Advocate General at the Court of Justice of the European Union in Luxembourg has concluded that the 8.3% dividend withholding tax pursuant to the BRK is not always permissible.…

Read more

Advocate General recommends further review on...

03 February, 2014 | News

On January 30, 2014, Ms. Van Hilten, the Advocate General attached to the Supreme Court, issued her independent opinion on the appeal a taxpayer had filed before the Supreme Court regarding…

Read more

International Corporate Tax Newsletter - Dece...

08 January, 2014 | News

Every month we publish an e-newsletter which gives you an overview of international tax developments being reported globally by KPMG member firms in the American, Africa, Europe and ASPAC…

Read more

Transfer of authority to deal with ‘catch all...

31 December, 2013 | News

To improve the speed with which requests for the application of the catch all clause contained in tax treaties are dealt with, the Ministry of Finance has decided to transfer the processing…

Read more

The Supreme Court requests preliminary ruling...

24 December, 2013 | News

The Supreme Court has requested preliminary rulings on Dutch dividend withholding tax levied on non-resident private shareholders and foreign companies.…

Read more

Tax treatment of additional Tier 1 capital

18 December, 2013 | News

Banks will be able to deduct, for tax purposes, the return on additional Tier 1 capital, even if it was issued after January 1, 2014.…

Read more

Main features new tax regulation between the ...

16 December, 2013 | News

On December 12, 2013, the Netherlands and Curaçao reached agreement on a new tax regulation for the avoidance of double taxation between the two countries.…

Read more

International Corporate Tax Newsletter - Nove...

06 December, 2013 | News

Every month we publish an e-newsletter which gives you an overview of international tax developments being reported globally by KPMG member firms in the American, Africa, Europe and ASPAC…

Read more

Deputy Minister of Finance releases new trans...

29 November, 2013 | News

On Tuesday, November 26, 2013, the Deputy Minister of Finance released a new transfer pricing decree which brings Dutch policy on transfer pricing in line with recent developments in this…

Read more

European Commission proposes amendments to Pa...

25 November, 2013 | News

On November 25, 2013, the European Commission proposed amendments to the EU Parent-Subsidiary Directive (“the Directive”) in order to close off perceived opportunities for corporate tax…

Read more

Supreme Court rules against Finnish investmen...

15 November, 2013 | News

The Supreme Court has ruled that a Finnish investment fund is not entitled to a refund of withheld Dutch dividend withholding tax.…

Read more

ITR World Tax 2014

13 November, 2013 | News

KPMG Meijburg & Co. has been ranked 'Tier 1' in the recently published ITR World Tax 2014.…

Read more

Germany imposes stricter conditions for zero ...

17 October, 2013 | News

Germany has increased the administrative burden for intra-Community supplies, i.e. the cross-border transport of goods within the European Union (EU). Customers must sign for receipt of the…

Read more

European social security

01 October, 2013 | Page

As a general rule, Dutch residents are compulsorily insured under national insurance legislation. Dutch national insurance legislation includes the following Acts: AOW (old-age pension…

Read more

European legal entities

01 October, 2013 | Page

At present, there are three supranational types of legal entities in the European Union:  European Economic Interest Grouping (EEIG) European public limited liability company, or…

Read more

European tax base

01 October, 2013 | Page

On October 23, 2001, the European Commission published a report entitled“Company taxation in the internal market.” It addresses problems regarding, for example, the limits to…

Read more

VAT Directive

01 October, 2013 | Page

The Dutch VAT system is based on European VAT rules and must be compatible with them. When it is not, taxpayers may choose to adopt the VAT position that benefits them the most, which may…

Read more

Directives on direct taxes

01 October, 2013 | Page

The application of the freedoms under the EC Treaty is sometimes referred to as “negative integration.” By contrast, “positive integration” refers to the European policies pursued…

Read more

Arbitration Convention

01 October, 2013 | Page

The Arbitration Convention entered into effect on January 1, 1995. Its aim is to eliminate double taxation in the event that tax authorities adjust profits associated enterprises realize…

Read more

Most-favored nation principle

01 October, 2013 | Page

Must non-Dutch resident taxpayers from different Member States be treated equally for tax purposes or, is the Netherlands allowed, for example, to treat residents of one Member State more…

Read more

Direct effect

01 October, 2013 | Page

The EU has various legal instruments at its disposal for realizing its objectives. Of these legal instruments, directives are the most pertinent to taxation, with regulations being less…

Read more

Non-discrimination in tax matters

01 October, 2013 | Page

There are three ways freedoms guaranteed by the EC Treaty may be impeded, either in whole or in part, by national tax legislation: direct discrimination indirect…

Read more

Treaty freedoms

01 October, 2013 | Page

The EC Treaty provides for a complete ban on discrimination based on nationality(Article 12), thus guaranteeing a number of freedoms. Article 12 only applies if no other, more specific…

Read more

Bill on deferral of payment of exit taxes

17 December, 2012 | Publications

The bill foresees an amendment to the Tax Collection Act and provides for the possibility of deferring payment for corporate and personal income tax purposes. This article discusses in…

Read more

Section 20a: the test moment tested

13 September, 2012 | Publications

Source: NTFR 2012/2126, pages 7-13 Author(s): Bauco Suvaal Uncertainty exists in the tax practice, and possibly also in judicial circles if a recent judgment rendered by the District Court…

Read more