Advocate General at CJEU issues Opinion on transactions between a head office and a fixed establishment that is part of a VAT group

Publication date 12 May 2014

On May 8, 2014 Advocate General (“AG”) Wathelet issued his Opinion in the Skandia America Corporation case. He concluded that transactions between a foreign head office and a fixed establishment that is part of a VAT group are outside the scope of VAT. However, it appears that the AG considers this an undesirable situation, because it means that transactions between the head office and the fixed establishment, as well as transactions within the VAT group, are not subject to VAT. The AG suggests a number of alternatives, under which the transactions would be subject to VAT.

1. The case

Skandia America Corporation (“Skandia”) is established in the United States and has a fixed establishment in Sweden. The fixed establishment is part of a Swedish VAT group. In 2007 and 2008, the US head office recharged (with a mark-up) externally acquired IT services to the Swedish fixed establishment. The Swedish fixed establishment modified the IT and, in turn, recharged the IT costs with a mark-up to the other group companies (both within and outside the VAT group).

The Swedish court requested a preliminary ruling from the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) on whether VAT is payable on the external services purchased by the head office that were allocated to the fixed establishment, given that the fixed establishment is part of a VAT group. If this was the case, it also asked whether the VAT reverse charge mechanism applied.

2. Opinion AG

The first fact established by the AG is that where a head office and a fixed establishment are part of one legal entity, they, together, form one single taxpayer. According to the AG, this means that both the fixed establishment and the head office are part of the VAT group. As such, the basis assumption is that no VAT is payable on the costs recharged to the Swedish fixed establishment.

The AG concluded that the fact that the fixed establishment (and the US head office) both are part of the VAT group means that not only (1) transactions between the head office and the fixed establishment, but also (2) transactions between the fixed establishment and the other companies in the VAT group are not subject to VAT. The AG considers the confluence of these two rules incompatible, because the services provided from the US to the companies making up the Swedish VAT group would then not be subject to VAT. The clause in the EU VAT Directive dealing with the VAT group allows measures that are necessary to prevent tax fraud and tax evasion and encourages measures to combat them. The AG therefore believes that the decision by the Swedish tax authorities to include the Swedish fixed establishment in the VAT group is contrary to the clause on VAT groups in the EU VAT Directive. It is subsequently up to the Swedish national courts to decide on the impact of this conclusion. The AG suggests four alternative approaches, which all have in common that VAT is payable on the IT services provided from the US. If the CJEU were to rule that the services between the head office and the fixed establishment are subject to VAT, then the AG believes that the VAT group must pay reverse charged VAT on these services.

The AG’s point of departure is therefore in line with current Dutch practice. Transactions between a foreign head office and a fixed establishment that is part of a VAT group are outside the scope of VAT. The four alternatives suggested by the AG may, however, result in VAT being payable. With regard to these alternatives, it would appear that they could not have retroactive effect in the Netherlands, and, depending on the alternative, it may be necessary to amend Dutch legislation.

3. What are your options?

At present, this only concerns an Opinion issued by the AG, which the CJEU is not obliged to follow. However, you can already take steps to determine what effect any future judgment by the CJEU will have on the VAT position of your business and what its financial impact will be. Because the VAT treatment of transactions between a foreign head office and a fixed establishment that are part of a VAT group is not harmonized throughout the Member States, it is essential that you not only thoroughly identify all the issues at stake in the Netherlands, but also do this for the other Member States. Depending on the Member State, it may still be possible to file an objection against the foreign VAT you currently pay on such transactions.

If you would like to discuss the AG’s Opinion, or if you would like to find out what effect the CJEU judgment could have on the VAT position of your business, please contact one of the advisors of the Indirect Tax Financial Services Group at KPMG Meijburg & Co, or your own Meijburg tax advisor.

Click here to download the memorandum in pdf format

   

International Tax Newsletter - November 2014

17 December, 2014 | News

Every month we publish an e-newsletter which gives you an overview of international tax developments being reported globally by KPMG member firms in the American, Africa, Europe and ASPAC…

Read more

European Council of Ministers approves genera...

11 December, 2014 | News

On December 9, 2014 the EU Council of Economics and Finance Ministers (ECOFIN) reached political agreement on, among other things, the inclusion of a general anti-abuse rule in the…

Read more

International Tax Newsletter - October 2014

04 December, 2014 | News

Every month we publish an e-newsletter which gives you an overview of international tax developments being reported globally by KPMG member firms in the American, Africa, Europe and ASPAC…

Read more

International Tax Newsletter - September 2014

03 November, 2014 | News

Every month we publish an e-newsletter which gives you an overview of international tax developments being reported globally by KPMG member firms in the American, Africa, Europe and ASPAC…

Read more

ITR World Tax Review 2015

20 October, 2014 | News

Meijburg & Co has been ranked 'Tier 1' in the recently published ITR World Tax 2015. CLICK HERE FOR THE COMPLETE GUIDE WITH LEADING TAX FIRMS  Meijburg has also been ranked…

Read more

FS Tax Newsletter Issue 16 | October 2014

02 October, 2014 | News

Dear FS professional, The FS Tax Newsletter of KPMG Meijburg & Co was introduced in April 2012 and is published every two months. The FS Tax Newsletter addresses recent…

Read more

Letter from the Deputy Minister of Finance on...

24 September, 2014 | News

According to this judgment, pension funds that operate a defined contribution plan (DC plan) can qualify, under certain conditions, as a common investment fund within the meaning of the VAT…

Read more

Judgment in Skandia America Corporation (C-7/...

22 September, 2014 | News

The Court of Justice of the European Union has ruled that services provided by a head office to a fixed establishment that is part of a VAT group are subject to VAT.…

Read more

OECD releases first recommendations action pl...

17 September, 2014 | News

On September 16, 2013, the OECD launched the first set of reports following its Action Plan to deal with base erosion and profit shifting (“BEPS”). The reports address 7 of the…

Read more

International Tax Newsletter - August 2014

08 September, 2014 | News

Every month we publish an e-newsletter which gives you an overview of international tax developments being reported globally by KPMG member firms in the American, Africa, Europe and ASPAC…

Read more

EU Tax Law app now available in the Apple App...

03 September, 2014 | News

KPMG Meijburg has launched a Beta version of an EU Tax Law app that contains all the rulings (including opinions) from the Court of Justice of the EU for Direct Tax, VAT and Social…

Read more

International Tax Newsletter - July 2014

14 August, 2014 | News

Every month we publish an e-newsletter which gives you an overview of international tax developments being reported globally by KPMG member firms in the American, Africa, Europe and ASPAC…

Read more

FS Tax Newsletter Issue 15 | August 2014

12 August, 2014 | News

Now that the end of the summer is approaching, why not ease back into business with some light reading in the form of our FS Tax Newsletter. The main topic this time is the introduction of…

Read more

VAT/GST Refunds Survey 2014

29 July, 2014 | Publications

Where in the world can businesses obtain a refund of VAT and GST, and how efficient is the process?KPMG’s Global Indirect Tax Services new VAT/GST Refunds Survey 2014 answers these…

Read more

FS Indirect Tax Newsletter | July 2014

08 July, 2014 | News

Dear FS Tax professional, As indicated in our last FS Tax newsletter, we hereby provide you with a separate FS Indirect Tax Newsletter. Also, in the FS Indirect Tax arena there is a number…

Read more

International Tax Newsletter - June 2014

07 July, 2014 | News

Every month we publish an e-newsletter which gives you an overview of international tax developments being reported globally by KPMG member firms in the American, Africa, Europe and ASPAC…

Read more

New Tax Regulation between the Netherlands an...

24 June, 2014 | News

On June 10, 2014 the new bilateral rules for the avoidance of double taxation between the Netherlands – including the Caribbean part – and Curaçao (“BRNC”) were announced and…

Read more

EU Council of Ministers agrees with amendment...

23 June, 2014 | News

The amendment means that payments received on cross-border hybrid loans will be excluded from tax exemption as from January 1, 2016.…

Read more

VAT exemption does not apply to discount card...

16 June, 2014 | News

On June 12, 2014 the Court of Justice of the European Union ruled that discount cards did not fall within the scope of ‘securities’ or of ‘other negotiable instruments’ for the…

Read more

International Tax Newsletter - May 2014

10 June, 2014 | News

Every month we publish an e-newsletter which gives you an overview of international tax developments being reported globally by KPMG member firms in the American, Africa, Europe and ASPAC…

Read more

Important decision by CJEU on the dividend wi...

06 June, 2014 | News

The Court of Justice of the European Union in Luxembourg has concluded that the 8.3% dividend withholding tax pursuant to the BRK is permissible subject to certain conditions. …

Read more

FS Tax Newsletter Issue 14 | June 2014

04 June, 2014 | News

Dear FS Tax professional, Plenty of topics to think about in the summer, for a large part relating to Banking regulations. Tax has become an additional item in Banking supervision, and…

Read more

Decision Dutch District Court on VAT treatmen...

13 May, 2014 | News

The District Court in The Hague recently rendered judgment in a case concerning the recharging of advisory fees by a bank. The bank had deployed an external advisor in connection with the…

Read more

International Tax Newsletter - april 2014

12 May, 2014 | News

Every month we publish an e-newsletter which gives you an overview of international tax developments being reported globally by KPMG member firms in the American, Africa, Europe and ASPAC…

Read more

Bitcoins: paying with homemade money?

09 April, 2014 | Publications

Source: Btw Brief 2014/39Author: Thomas van Ditzhuijsen and Niels Wenting A Bitcoin is a digital payment instrument. The number of companies worldwide that accept Bitcoins is…

Read more

International Tax Newsletter - March 2014

07 April, 2014 | News

Every month we publish an e-newsletter which gives you an overview of international tax developments being reported globally by KPMG member firms in the American, Africa, Europe and ASPAC…

Read more

FS Tax Newsletter Issue 13 | April 2014

03 April, 2014 | News

Dear FS professional, We are pleased to present you with the April issue of the FS Tax Newsletter. In this issue we look at the Capital Requirements Directive IV (which implements Basel…

Read more

OECD issued public discussion draft on tax ch...

28 March, 2014 | News

On March 24, 2014, the OECD released a public discussion draft on the tax challenges of the digital economy, as part of its base erosion and profit-shifting action plan (Action 1).…

Read more

European Council agreed to adopt amendments t...

21 March, 2014 | News

On March 20, 2014 Luxembourg has agreed to a proposed revision of the EU Savings Directive. This clears the path for the EU Council of Ministers to adopt the amendments in the Savings…

Read more

OECD issued public discussion drafts on neutr...

20 March, 2014 | News

On 19 March 2014, the OECD released two public discussion drafts on the development of model treaty provisions and recommendations for the design of domestic rules to neutralize the effect…

Read more

OECD issued public discussion draft on tax tr...

17 March, 2014 | News

Recently, the OECD issued a public discussion draft on tax treaty abuse as part of its base erosion and profit-shifting action plan.…

Read more

International Tax Newsletter - February 2014

07 March, 2014 | News

Every month we publish an e-newsletter which gives you an overview of international tax developments being reported globally by KPMG member firms in the American, Africa, Europe and ASPAC…

Read more

Tax Intelligence Solution

21 February, 2014 | Page

Do you want to identify your VAT risks and opportunities on time, based on facts, so that you can subsequently take appropriate action? And do you want to spare your IT colleagues a lot of…

Read more

International Tax Newsletter - January 2014

11 February, 2014 | News

Every month we publish an e-newsletter which gives you an overview of international tax developments being reported globally by KPMG member firms in the American, Africa, Europe and ASPAC…

Read more

Important advice by Advocate General at CJEU ...

06 February, 2014 | News

The Advocate General at the Court of Justice of the European Union in Luxembourg has concluded that the 8.3% dividend withholding tax pursuant to the BRK is not always permissible.…

Read more

Advocate General recommends further review on...

03 February, 2014 | News

On January 30, 2014, Ms. Van Hilten, the Advocate General attached to the Supreme Court, issued her independent opinion on the appeal a taxpayer had filed before the Supreme Court regarding…

Read more

Intergovernmental Agreement between Netherlan...

08 January, 2014 | News

Representatives of the Netherlands and the United States signed an intergovernmental agreement for the automatic exchange of data between the tax authorities of both countries, thus…

Read more

VAT adjustment private use of company car for...

03 January, 2014 | News

The Dutch tax authorities have stated that if an objection was filed against the assessed amount of the VAT adjustment for the private use of a company car for 2011 or 2012, no objection…

Read more

Transfer of authority to deal with ‘catch all...

31 December, 2013 | News

To improve the speed with which requests for the application of the catch all clause contained in tax treaties are dealt with, the Ministry of Finance has decided to transfer the processing…

Read more

The Supreme Court requests preliminary ruling...

24 December, 2013 | News

The Supreme Court has requested preliminary rulings on Dutch dividend withholding tax levied on non-resident private shareholders and foreign companies.…

Read more

FS Tax Newsletter Issue 11 | December 2013

19 December, 2013 | News

Dear FS professional, This is the final newsletter for 2013. The majority of issues discussed in this newsletter relate to increased regulation for financial institutions. CRD IV lays down…

Read more

Tax treatment of additional Tier 1 capital

18 December, 2013 | News

Banks will be able to deduct, for tax purposes, the return on additional Tier 1 capital, even if it was issued after January 1, 2014.…

Read more

Main features new tax regulation between the ...

16 December, 2013 | News

On December 12, 2013, the Netherlands and Curaçao reached agreement on a new tax regulation for the avoidance of double taxation between the two countries.…

Read more

Taxation of real estate investment trusts

09 December, 2013 | Publications

An overview of the REIT regimes in Europe, Asia and the Americas.…

Read more

International Corporate Tax Newsletter - Nove...

06 December, 2013 | News

Every month we publish an e-newsletter which gives you an overview of international tax developments being reported globally by KPMG member firms in the American, Africa, Europe and ASPAC…

Read more

European Commission proposes amendments to Pa...

25 November, 2013 | News

On November 25, 2013, the European Commission proposed amendments to the EU Parent-Subsidiary Directive (“the Directive”) in order to close off perceived opportunities for corporate tax…

Read more

The VAT position of self-employed health care...

21 November, 2013 | Publications

Various judgments were recently rendered on the VAT consequences of using the services of self-employed medical staff; the results varied. The Lower House as well as the media are paying…

Read more

Supreme Court rules against Finnish investmen...

15 November, 2013 | News

The Supreme Court has ruled that a Finnish investment fund is not entitled to a refund of withheld Dutch dividend withholding tax.…

Read more

ITR World Tax 2014

13 November, 2013 | News

KPMG Meijburg & Co. has been ranked 'Tier 1' in the recently published ITR World Tax 2014.…

Read more

Request for preliminary ruling from the Court...

08 November, 2013 | News

On November 1, 2013, the Supreme Court requested a preliminary ruling from the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) on the VAT treatment of the management of real estate…

Read more

Services provided to mortgage lenders subject...

18 October, 2013 | News

On October 11, 2013, the Supreme Court ruled that payment and collection services provided to mortgage lenders are subject to VAT…

Read more

VATAutomation

04 October, 2013 | Page

Can you meet all your statutory VAT obligations? Can you accomplish this in all the EU Member States in which you operate as an entrepreneur? Are you certain that, where intragroup…

Read more

VAT training

04 October, 2013 | Page

Meijburg & Co can offer you an in-house course, training, or workshop that is geared specifically to your company’s needs. This involves tailor-made solutions: you decide, in consultation…

Read more

VAT Quick scan

04 October, 2013 | Page

Meijburg & Co’s VAT quick scan is a simple and efficient tool that helps entrepreneurs determine whether they run any VAT compliance risks. Furthermore, it identifies potential VAT-saving…

Read more

Tax Plan 2014: acquisition of an interest of ...

03 October, 2013 | News

Under current legislation, acquisitions of interests of less than one third in real estate entities are not subject to real estate transfer tax, while acquisitions of one third or more are…

Read more

Fiscal investment institutions can − indirect...

02 October, 2013 | News

Fiscal investment institutions are subject to a 0% corporate income tax rate, provided they meet certain conditions. One of these conditions is that the fiscal investment institution only…

Read more

Indirect Tax – Insurance

01 October, 2013 | Page

The advisors of Meijburg & Co’s Indirect Tax Financial Services group have extensive experience in not only identifying the VAT risks associated with insurance products, but also the VAT…

Read more

Indirect Tax – Investment management

01 October, 2013 | Page

The advisors of Meijburg & Co’s Indirect Tax Financial Services group have extensive experience not only in identifying the VAT risks confronting institutional investors and their asset…

Read more

Indirect Tax – Financial services

01 October, 2013 | Page

The advisors of Meijburg & Co’s Indirect Tax Financial Services group have extensive experience in identifying the VAT risks confronting financial institutions, but also the VAT…

Read more

Indirect Tax – Payment Services

01 October, 2013 | Page

The advisors of Meijburg & Co’s Indirect Tax Financial Services group have extensive experience in not only identifying the VAT risks confronting payment service providers, but also the…

Read more

Indirect Tax – Banking

01 October, 2013 | Page

Meijburg & Co’s Indirect Tax Financial Services Group advises clients active in the banking industry. Our specialists have extensive experience with identifying VAT risks, advising on…

Read more

The Netherlands-United Kingdom Treaty for the...

01 October, 2013 | News

The Dutch government has introduced a bank tax on the banking sector aimed at recovering the money lent as financial support to the banks during the financial crisis. This bank tax took…

Read more

Financial Services: Banking

27 September, 2013 | Page

Meijburg & Co has long been a leader in providing tax advisory services to a large number of national and international financial institutions. This has enabled our advisors to gain…

Read more

VAT

18 September, 2013 | Page

Every purchaser and supplier of goods or services has to deal with value added tax (VAT). VAT on the regular purchase and sale of goods and services generally runs smoothly and does not…

Read more

Companies can recover the VAT charged on cost...

26 July, 2013 | News

On July 18, 2013, the Court of Justice of the European Union ("CJEU") rendered judgment in the PPG Holdings BV case (C-26/12) concerning the recovery of VAT charged on costs incurred by a…

Read more

The 2013 Benchmark Survey on VAT/GST

03 May, 2013 | Publications

The 2013 Benchmark Survey on VAT/GST provides valuable insights into emerging best practices, benchmarks and global and regional trends.…

Read more

The management of pension funds implementing ...

07 March, 2013 | News

On March 7, 2013, the Court of Justice of the European Union ("CJEU") rendered its judgment in the Wheels Common Investment Fund Trustees Ltd case (C-424/11) on the VAT position of the…

Read more

Financial Transaction Tax

01 January, 2013 | News

The European Commission’s proposal for an EU wide tax on financial transactions (FTT) has generated much public and political discussion since it was published on September 28,…

Read more

Customs duties vs. VAT; strict vs. flexible?

11 February, 2012 | Publications

The Court of Justice of the European Union recently ruled that a customs debt arises if administrative obligations are not met. This is also the case if the goods were re-exported; a fact…

Read more

FS Tax Newsletter (archive 2012 & 2013)

05 November, 2010 | Page

The Meijburg & Co Financial Services Tax Group is proud to present its FS Tax Newsletters. The FS Tax Newsletter is published every two months and addresses recent developments in FS…

Read more